In the tragic final scene of Romeo and Juliet, Paris stands guard at Juliet's tomb, grieving her supposed death. When Romeo arrives to take his own life beside Juliet, Paris hears him and, not recognizing him in the darkness, demands to know who is approaching. This tense moment heightens the tragedy as the two men, both devoted to Juliet, unknowingly stand on the brink of a fatal confrontation.
Friar Laurence: "Who is it?"
In modern day english, we would say:
Someone asks who is there.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is speaking when Friar Laurence says Who is it?
Friar Laurence is the one speaking.
Connections to other verses:
Connections to "Who is it?" in Romeo & Juliet Act 5, Scene 3
The verse Who is it? is spoken by Balthasar, Romeo's servant, as he hears a noise and questions who might be approaching the Capulet tomb. This moment of uncertainty and tension connects to several other verses in the scene, reflecting themes of discovery, fear, and tragic revelation.
Immediate Context and Suspense
Balthasar's query arises as he stands watch outside the tomb, having accompanied Romeo but remaining at a distance. This aligns with Romeo's earlier instruction in Whate'er thou hear'st or seest, stand all aloof, emphasizing secrecy and the foreboding atmosphere. The sense of impending discovery is echoed when Paris, also at the tomb, wonders What cursed foot wanders this way to-night, highlighting the shared anxiety of unexpected intruders in this somber setting.
Revelation and Identity
The question "Who is it?" ultimately leads to the tragic unveiling of the scene's events. It precedes the entrance of the Watch and others, who later seek to uncover the truth, as in Search, seek, and know how this foul murder comes. Balthasar's presence and his subsequent testimony (I brought my master news of Juliet's death) become crucial in piecing together the tragedy, tying his initial uncertainty to the broader investigation.
Emotional and Narrative Links
This moment also connects to the theme of mistaken identity and grief. For instance, when Juliet awakens, she asks Where is my Romeo?, a poignant contrast to Balthasar's question, as both characters seek answers in the midst of confusion and loss. Additionally, the Prince's later inquiry Where's Romeo's man? what can he say in this? directly involves Balthasar, showing how his simple question sets in motion the explanation of the entire tragic sequence.



























































