In Act 1, Scene 1 of Romeo and Juliet, Benvolio notices his cousin Romeo behaving unusually withdrawn and melancholic. Concerned, he asks this question to Romeo's father, Montague, who has also observed his son's prolonged sadness. The line reflects the early establishment of Romeo's lovesick nature, which sets the tone for his character and the unfolding drama.
Benvolio: "It was. What sadness lengthens Romeo's hours?"
In modern day english, we would say:
Romeo has been acting sad lately—what’s making him so miserable?
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is asking about Romeo's sadness in Act 1 Scene 1?
Benvolio
What does Benvolio notice about Romeo in this scene?
He notices that Romeo seems sad and his hours feel longer
In Act 1 Scene 1, what emotion is Romeo showing?
Sadness
Connections to other verses:
Connections to Romeo's Melancholy
The verse "It was. What sadness lengthens Romeo's hours?" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-157/) is spoken by Benvolio, expressing concern for Romeo's unusual sorrow. This inquiry directly connects to Romeo's own lament in "Not having that, which, having, makes them short", where Romeo reveals that his hours feel long because he lacks the joy (love) that would make time fly. Further emphasizing his state, Romeo describes love as "A choking gall and a preserving sweet" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-191/), capturing love's dual nature of pain and pleasure, which consumes him.
Expressions of Romeo's Emotional State
Romeo's withdrawn behavior is noted by Montague, who says he "pens himself" in his chamber and "makes himself an artificial night" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-130/, /romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-132/), avoiding daylight and company. His sighs are described as "Adding to clouds more clouds with his deep sighs" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-125/), painting a vivid image of his gloom. Romeo himself admits, "Griefs of mine own lie heavy in my breast" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-183/), confirming the weight of his sadness.
Contrast with the Scene's Violence
Romeo's introspection starkly contrasts with the public brawling, such as when Sampson provocatively says, "A dog of the house of Montague moves me" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-7/), igniting the feud. The Prince's intervention, "Throw your mistemper'd weapons to the ground" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-80/), highlights the external conflict that Romeo's internal turmoil exists alongside, yet apart from.
Philosophical Reflections on Love
Romeo's sorrow leads him to ponder love's contradictions, calling it "a smoke raised with the fume of sighs" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-187/) and lamenting, "This love feel I, that feel no love in this" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-177/). Benvolio's advice to "Examine other beauties" (/romeo-and-juliet/one/1-1/act-1-scene-1-227/) is rebuffed by Romeo's steadfastness, showing how his sadness defines his current existence.

























































