In Act 3 Scene 3 of Romeo and Juliet, Romeo reacts with despair upon learning he has been banished from Verona as punishment for killing Tybalt. Friar Laurence tries to console him, but Romeo sees banishment as a fate worse than death, believing it will separate him from Juliet forever. This moment captures his anguish and inability to imagine life without her.
Romeo: "But 'banished' to kill me?--'banished'?"
In modern day english, we would say:
You're saying banishment is the same as death—banishment is a death sentence?
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Romeo upset about being banished?
Romeo is upset because he believes that being banished from Verona, where Juliet lives, is worse than death since it means he cannot be with her.
Connections to other verses:
Connections to "But 'banished' to kill me?--'banished'?"
This verse reflects Romeo's despair and inability to see beyond his immediate suffering. It connects thematically and emotionally with several other lines in the scene.
Related to the Nature of Banishment
Romeo's anguished repetition of "banished" echoes his earlier cry: "Ha, banishment! be merciful, say 'death;'", where he explicitly equates banishment with a fate worse than death. This idea is reinforced in "And world's exile is death: then banished", framing exile as a living death. The Friar's attempt to rationalize the punishment as mercy in "This is dear mercy, and thou seest it not" contrasts sharply with Romeo's perspective.
Expressions of Despair and Hyperbole
Romeo's dramatic question about banishment killing him aligns with his later extreme declaration in "And say'st thou yet that exile is not death?", showing his persistent refusal to accept any comfort. His metaphorical language finds a parallel in "Thou cutt'st my head off with a golden axe", where he again portrays mercy as a cruel and painful act.
Rebellion Against Reason
The Friar's counsel, including the mention of "Adversity's sweet milk, philosophy", is dismissed by Romeo's emotional state, culminating in his rejection: "Yet 'banished'? Hang up philosophy!". This dismissal highlights the clash between rational advice and overwhelming grief.
Connection to Juliet and Love
Romeo's focus on the pain of separation is rooted in his love for Juliet, emphasized in lines like "And steal immortal blessing from her lips", illustrating what he believes he has lost. The Nurse's later news about Juliet's distress in "O, she says nothing, sir, but weeps and weeps" further deepens the tragic consequences of his banishment.


























































