In Act 2, Scene 5 of Romeo and Juliet, Juliet impatiently awaits news from her nurse about Romeo's plans for their secret marriage. When the nurse finally returns, Juliet, anxious and eager, cuts off her rambling with this direct question, demanding clarity. The line captures Juliet's youthful urgency and the high stakes of their forbidden love.
Juliet: "Is thy news good, or bad? answer to that;"
In modern day english, we would say:
Is your news good or bad? Just tell me that.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Juliet asking the Nurse in this line?
Juliet is asking the Nurse if the news she has is good or bad.
Connections to other verses:
Connections to "Is thy news good, or bad? answer to that;"
This line, spoken by Juliet, reflects her intense anxiety and impatience as she awaits the Nurse's report on Romeo. It underscores the emotional stakes of the scene, where news from Romeo could mean either joy or despair.
Related Verses on Anticipation and Impatience
- Juliet's earlier plea, O honey nurse, what news?, shows her eagerness, directly leading to her demand for a binary answer.
- Her frustration with delay is echoed in The excuse that thou dost make in this delay / Is longer than the tale thou dost excuse, emphasizing her impatience.
- Juliet's insistence on clarity is mirrored in Let me be satisfied, is't good or bad?, reinforcing her need for immediate resolution.
Contrast with the Nurse's Attitude
- The Nurse's playful evasion, such as in I' faith, I am sorry that thou art not well, contrasts with Juliet's urgency, heightening the tension.
- Her complaints about physical discomfort, like Fie, how my bones ache! what a jaunt have I had!, delay the news, frustrating Juliet further.
Thematic Links to Love and Communication
- Juliet's ideal that love's heralds should be thoughts highlights her belief in swift, direct communication, opposed to the Nurse's sluggishness.
- The eventual revelation in There stays a husband to make you a wife provides the "good news" Juliet sought, resolving her anxiety.


























































