In Act 3 Scene 3 of Romeo and Juliet, Friar Laurence scolds Romeo for his excessive despair after being banished from Verona. The line refers to Romeo's melodramatic grief, as the friar questions why he has sunk into such overwhelming sorrow. This moment highlights Romeo's impulsive nature and the friar's attempt to reason with him.
Nurse: "Why should you fall into so deep an O?"
In modern day english, we would say:
Why are you getting so upset over nothing?
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the Nurse mean when she asks why someone would fall into such a deep sadness?
The Nurse is expressing concern and confusion about why Romeo is so deeply upset, referring to his extreme sorrow over being banished from Verona and separated from Juliet.
Connections to other verses:
Connections to "Why should you fall into so deep an O?"
The line "Why should you fall into so deep an O?" is spoken by Friar Laurence, questioning Romeo's excessive despair. This connects thematically and emotionally to several other verses in the scene:
Despair and Emotional Collapse
Romeo's deep lamentation is echoed in his physical and emotional collapse, as seen when he "fall[s] upon the ground" and when the Friar notes Juliet's similar distress, "Piteous predicament! Even so lies she". Both lovers mirror each other's suffering, amplifying the sense of shared tragedy.
Critique of Romeo's Behavior
Friar Laurence repeatedly challenges Romeo's extreme reaction, asking "Art thou a man?" and criticizing his "womanish" tears and "Unseemly woman in a seeming man". The "deep an O" represents this unmanly, excessive grief the Friar condemns.
Banishment as Central Anguish
The core of Romeo's despair is his banishment, which he equates with death in "world's exile is death" and "exile is not death?". The "O" symbolizes his vocalized agony over this punishment, which he feels destroys his life.
Contrast with Juliet's State
The Nurse's description of Juliet's incessant weeping "she says nothing, sir, but weeps and weeps" parallels Romeo's "deep an O," showing their mutual, inconsolable sorrow. Friar Laurence uses this to spur Romeo to action, urging him to "rise and stand" for Juliet's sake.
Rejection of Comfort
Romeo's deep despair causes him to reject rational comfort, dismissing the Friar's philosophical advice "Hang up philosophy!" and "It helps not, it prevails not". The "O" represents his surrender to emotion over reason.



























































