In Act 4, Scene 5 of Romeo and Juliet, the Capulet household believes Juliet has died, and preparations for her funeral begin. Amidst the grief, Peter and the musicians engage in a brief, ironic exchange about the appropriateness of music, questioning why certain terms like "silver sound" are used to describe it. This moment offers a darkly comic contrast to the tragedy unfolding around them.
Peter: "why 'silver sound'? why 'music with her silver"
In modern day english, we would say:
Why call it a silver sound or say music has a silver tone when music brings no joy in this sad moment?
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Peter mention silver when talking about music in Romeo and Juliet?
Peter refers to 'silver sound' to describe the pleasant, high-quality tone of the music, as silver is often associated with beauty and value.
Connections to other verses:
Why 'silver sound'? Musical and Thematic Connections
The phrase "music with her silver sound" appears in this verse as part of Peter's witty exchange with the musicians. The choice of "silver" connects to both literal and metaphorical meanings within the scene. As explained in Marry, sir, because silver hath a sweet sound, the word suggests both the precious metal and the pleasing quality of music, contrasting with the grim reality of Juliet's supposed death.
Contrast with Mourning and Death
The joyful connotations of "silver sound" starkly oppose the pervasive grief expressed throughout the scene. Verses like Alack the day, she's dead, she's dead, she's dead! and Accursed, unhappy, wretched, hateful day! emphasize sorrow, making the musical reference ironic. This irony deepens when Capulet states in Our wedding cheer to a sad burial feast, highlighting the transformation of celebration into mourning.
Musicians' Role and Wordplay
The musicians' pragmatic response in Faith, we may put up our pipes, and be gone underscores their detachment from the tragedy, while Peter's playful banter, including I say 'silver sound,' because musicians sound for silver, ties "silver" to payment, adding a layer of economic realism amidst the emotional chaos.
Spiritual and Ironic Elevation
The idea of "silver sound" also contrasts with the scene's spiritual references, such as Above the clouds, as high as heaven itself?, where heaven symbolizes Juliet's ascent. The music's ethereal quality ironically underscores the tragedy, as noted in Our solemn hymns to sullen dirges change, where celebratory music turns funereal.



























































