In Act 4, Scene 5 of Romeo and Juliet, the Capulet household is in chaos after Juliet is found seemingly lifeless on the morning of her wedding to Paris. The musicians hired for the celebration, now unneeded, linger awkwardly, and when Peter, the Capulet servant, jokingly asks them what they will offer to lighten the mood, one responds with this line, blending dark humor with the scene's tension.
First Musician: "What will you give us?"
In modern day english, we would say:
What do you offer us in return?
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is speaking in this line from Romeo and Juliet?
The First Musician
What is the First Musician asking for in this line?
They are asking what they will be given or paid
In which act and scene does this line appear?
Act 4, Scene 5
Connections to other verses:
Connections to "What will you give us?"
The verse What will you give us? marks a sharp tonal shift from the tragic discovery of Juliet's apparent death to the mundane, almost comical interaction with the musicians. This line, spoken by Peter, serves as a bridge between the intense grief of the Capulet household and the detached, practical concerns of the hired performers.
Contrast with Mourning and Grief
This question starkly contrasts with the surrounding expressions of sorrow, such as the Nurse's exclamation Alas, alas! Help, help! my lady's dead! and Capulet's lament Accursed, unhappy, wretched, hateful day!. While the family is consumed by grief, Peter and the musicians are focused on payment, highlighting the disconnect between personal tragedy and professional obligations.
Link to Musical References
The query about compensation ties directly to the musicians' later discussions, such as their refusal to play without pay in because musicians have no gold for sounding and Peter's witty retort in I will then give it you soundly. This exchange underscores the theme of art's commodification, even in the face of death.
Juxtaposition with Ceremonial Irony
The question also contrasts with the transformation of wedding preparations into funeral rites, as seen in lines like Our wedding cheer to a sad burial feast. While the household repurposes its festivities for mourning, the musicians remain fixated on their fee, emphasizing the incongruity of life's practicalities amidst profound loss.
Connection to Peter's Character
Peter's role here aligns with his earlier attempts to rouse Juliet, such as Why, lamb! why, lady! fie, you slug-a-bed!, showcasing his blend of earnestness and humor. His pragmatic concern for payment adds a layer of dark comedy, relieving the scene's heaviness while underscoring the abrupt shift from celebration to despair.



























































