In Act 4, Scene 5 of Romeo and Juliet, the Capulet household believes Juliet has died, and chaos ensues as they prepare for her funeral. Amidst the commotion, the musicians hired for her wedding are still present, and Peter, a servant, engages in a brief, darkly comic exchange with them. His question to Simon Catling, one of the musicians, reflects the absurdity of their situation—asked to play joyful music in a moment of grief.
Peter: "sound'? What say you, Simon Catling?"
In modern day english, we would say:
Are you there, Simon Catling? What do you say?
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Peter talking to in this line from Romeo and Juliet?
Simon Catling
Connections to other verses:
Connections to "sound'? What say you, Simon Catling?"
The verse sound'? What say you, Simon Catling? is part of a musical interlude that contrasts sharply with the tragic events of the scene. It connects thematically and tonally to several other verses:
Musical and Thematic Contrast
- Directly follows why 'silver sound'? why 'music with her silver, which questions the choice of words, emphasizing the musicians' role in providing solace or irony.
- Preceded by Then music with her silver sound'--, introducing the idea of music's comforting power amid grief.
- Contrasts with the despair in verses like Alack the day, she's dead, she's dead, she's dead!, highlighting the scene's shift from wedding joy to funeral sorrow.
Character Interactions and Humor
- Part of a exchange with other musicians, as seen in Pretty! What say you, Hugh Rebeck? and Pretty too! What say you, James Soundpost?, adding a layer of dark humor.
- Reflects the musicians' pragmatic view, echoed in Faith, we may put up our pipes, and be gone., underscoring their detachment from the tragedy.
Symbolism of Sound and Silence
- Opposes the silence of death described in Life and these lips have long been separated:, where music becomes a futile attempt to counteract loss.
- Connects to Not a dump we; 'tis no time to play now., emphasizing the inappropriateness of music in mourning.



























































