In Act 2, Scene 4 of Romeo and Juliet, Mercutio and Benvolio are teasing the Nurse, who has come to find Romeo with a message from Juliet. When the Nurse reacts sharply to their bawdy humor, she scolds one of them with this exasperated line, showing her no-nonsense attitude. The moment highlights the playful yet tense dynamic between the Nurse and Romeo’s quick-witted friends.
Nurse: "Out upon you! what a man are you!"
In modern day english, we would say:
Wow, what kind of man are you!
Frequently Asked Questions
Who says this line in Act 2 Scene 4 of Romeo and Juliet?
The Nurse
What emotion is the Nurse likely expressing in this line?
Frustration or annoyance
Is the Nurse speaking to Romeo or Juliet in this scene?
Romeo
Connections to other verses:
Connections to "Out upon you! what a man are you!"
The verse "Out upon you! what a man are you!" is spoken by the Nurse, expressing her frustration and indignation. This line connects thematically and contextually to several other verses in the scene, particularly those involving the Nurse's interactions and the broader themes of mockery, identity, and social expectations.
Mockery and Wordplay
This exclamation aligns with the scene's prevalent use of mockery and puns. For instance, Mercutio's taunting of Romeo in "now art thou sociable, now art thou Romeo" highlights a shift in Romeo's behavior, much like the Nurse's outburst critiques the perceived inadequacies of those around her. Similarly, the playful yet sharp exchange in "Thy wit is a very bitter sweeting" underscores the tension between humor and criticism, a dynamic present in the Nurse's line.
Social Critique and Identity
The Nurse's remark questions masculinity and social standing, echoing other critiques in the scene. Mercutio's description of Tybalt as "More than prince of cats" and a "courageous captain of compliments" satirizes the posturing of young men, paralleling the Nurse's frustration with empty boasts or failures to meet expectations. Additionally, Romeo's self-deprecating acknowledgment in "my business was great" touches on the theme of personal justification, which the Nurse's line challenges directly.
Interactions with the Nurse
The Nurse's character is central here, and her exchanges provide further context. Her later line, "Now, afore God, I am so vexed", mirrors the exasperation in "Out upon you!". Similarly, her pragmatic yet humorous nature is evident in "but first let me tell ye, if ye should lead her...", where she blends concern with critique, much like in the focal verse.
Resolution and Forward Motion
Despite the tension, the scene moves toward resolution, as seen in Romeo's arrangements with the Nurse, such as "This afternoon, sir? well, she shall be there". The Nurse's outburst, while critical, is part of the negotiation process, highlighting the clash between emotion and practicality in advancing the plot toward the secret marriage.



























































